People often complain that the border reivers get a bad press and that history has misrepresented them somehow, that they were just doing what they had to do to get by and it was a matter of survival.
The reality is that many other families were living in the border country and didn’t get as involved in the cattle thieving gangs as much as the more notorious names, so they don’t show up in the records as regularly.
Take, for example, the Youngers.
There are still many of the family living in Northumberland. I went to school with Keith Younger, a farm lad from up the Coquet valley, where the family are still fairly numerous.
The Youngers never get mentioned in reiver stories, though they were there, and they’re just one of many others that didn’t get together in family raiding gangs to terrorise their neighbours.
There were people with other familiar local surnames such as Hutchison, Dobson, Ramshaw, Golightly, Willie, Maughan, Atkinson, Swan, Lee. Wood, Pigg, Riddle, Whitfield and many more living among the rural communities around the Hexham area in 1538 when a comprehensive muster roll of the whole county was taken – and it was the same on both sides of the border.
There was one family of Youngers living at Hallington near Kirkheaton with William, Roger, Gerard, Willie, Robert, three Johns and a Phillip all ‘able with horse and harness’ within the small rural community.
The common misconception is that the whole countryside was filled with lawless people when, in fact, the reivers were a select group of criminals in the community with their surnames and reputations giving that protection against prosecution from the others that did not dare complain against them for fear of retribution.
To be a border reiver was a badge of notoriety, and having a border surname is not the same as having a riding surname. Likewise, many of the people with a riding surname were not actually involved in the criminal activities of their kinsmen.
The Youngers did, however, become a notorious name synonymous with crime by the time that some of them moved West across into America. Who hasn’t heard of Cole, Jim, John and Bob who joined the Confederate Bushwhackers with Jesse and Frank James during the US Civil War?
Theirs is a story, like many more, that might have its origins back in ancestry to rural Northumberland.